Subrogation Specialist to join their growing team. Known for exceptional service, profitable growth, and a people-first culture, this organization blends rich tradition with innovative thinking—all in a remote-first environment that encourages work-life balance and authenticity.

The RoleReporting to the Leader, Accident Benefits, the Subrogation Specialist is responsible for managing subrogation activities across all lines of business, including Auto and Property, and across several policy types such as Residential, Farm, Commercial, Accident Benefits, and Bodily Injury.

This individual plays a critical role in identifying, evaluating, and pursuing subrogation opportunities to support the company's financial performance. From investigations to settlements, they apply subject matter expertise to strengthen internal practices and collaborate across the claims department, especially during peak periods or catastrophic events.

Key Responsibilities

Investigate and negotiate settlements with third parties on subrogation matters

Represent the company in small claims court proceedings

Collaborate with legal counsel to prepare court documents, evidence, and statements

Maintain strong legal and technical knowledge related to subrogation

Manage recoveries across subrogation types (property, auto, loss transfer, priority, overpayments, etc.)

Ensure financial accuracy through proactive reserve management

Support claims teams with guidance and consultative input

Who You Are

A collaborative team player who works closely with claims adjusters and leadership

Proactive, adaptable, and ready to embrace change

Relationship-builder who supports strategic company goals

Qualifications

Minimum 5 years of experience in P&C insurance, with direct claims and subrogation experience

Post-secondary education

CIP designation completed or in progress

Strong negotiation, analytical, and problem-solving skills

Detail-oriented with excellent judgment and decision-making abilities

Paralegal license with the Law Society of Ontario is an asset

Proficiency with Microsoft Office; familiarity with Guidewire ClaimCenter is an asset

Understanding of case law and insurance policies across personal, commercial, and farm lines

What's in It for You

Flexible work arrangements (remote-first)

Competitive compensation package

Parental leave top-up

Comprehensive pension and savings programs

Paid volunteer days

Ongoing training and development opportunities